A family came to me recently with a question that many people have thought about: "Alice, can I stop working at 50?"

For context, couple is in their 40’s with a net worth of about $4.7M. 

They require a monthly income of ~$17k after-tax (combined) to maintain their lifestyle, live comfortably, and financially support their young children through college.

For tax purposes, they file as MFJ (married filing jointly) and are in the 22% federal tax bracket.

Breakdown: 

  • Real estate equity in primary residence + 3 rentals = $1.8m  

  • Pre-tax accounts: $1.21m  

  • Brokerage: $1.6m 

  • Kids’ 529’s and Roth IRAs: $100k 

  • Roth IRAs: $30k 


Tax-Advantaged Accounts
I recommended that at their pre-tax account balance, they stop making annual contributions to pre-tax accounts and start making roth 401k contributions instead. This prevents them from tying up money until age 59.5 and a major RMD issue from happening at 75. I mapped out a small roth conversion schedule for them which should effectively save them ~$30k in lifetime tax.

The wife also had a Roth IRA that was underutilized, mostly held in bond funds, which I suggested was too conservative and better to go into individual equities. Her 401k already held Vanguard target date funds.

Asset Allocation
They previously had another wealth management platform that built a portfolio for them 10 years ago. The portfolio held individual names only and was more defensive in nature. It wasn’t a bad selection, but it was never professionally rebalanced since then. As a result it became slowly underexposed to tech, meaning that it likely trailed the S&P500 over the last 5 years. The husband made additional self-directed contributions to index ETFs that he gathered from watching finance influencer videos.

 77 Individual equities + ~30 ETFs = ~100 holdings in total. 

All of their holdings 

Portfolio Allocation

  • The first thing that this portfolio could use is trimming down of holdings from 100+ to max 50. Even 50 is on the high(er) end. 

  • The international stock weighting is a bit high. This is a diversification choice but it means his portfolio is underweighted in Mag7. I would trim down a bit on international holdings here.   

  • Individual equities are split 75% large cap, 14% mid cap, and 11% small cap (IWM, VBR). This mix is okay, but IWM for example is more used by traders and SCHA has a better fee structure for the same thing. 

  • If I were managing this portfolio more actively I would keep this at 80% individual equities and consider put a heavier weighting into power/energy (long term power thesis for AI centre demand) and right now consumer staples (food, beverages) which has gone up recently as capital continues to rotate out for the AI trade, even as I am writing this

  • Most of their bonds are in US treasuries, which I think is just fine to keep as is. Even though investment grade corporate bonds have attractive yields today at ~5.9% (spreads have narrowed from Nov 5-12), I’d still say it’s not necessary to increase the bond holdings and just keep most it with equities

  • The portfolio will need a significant rebalance again near retirement, one option of which would be to turn this into a more defensive income generating portfolio. 

  • There was a little bit of overlap with ETFs in his existing portfolio, which is inevitable when your portfolio is built off of ETFs.  

  • Gold, real estate funds, and BTC: no need to change, but BTC just hit $64k which is an attractive entry point if you’re patient to hold it long term (could take years).

  • Fee drag on their entire portfolio is around $6k a year which is okay against $2.85M for a 100% DIY portfolio. This fee is not tax deductible.  

Real Estate 

  • 2 of their 3 properties are cash flowing very well and are good investments 

  • The short-term rental could use a cost segregation study done to take advantage of bonus depreciation against a year with high expected income. If they meet the IRS rules to qualify for the short term rental tax loophole, they can use paper losses to offset ordinary income. 

  • 1 of their 3 properties is operating at break-even, which they can sell or could utilize a 1031 exchange to roll into a better performing property if they want to. Or they could just hold it forever for equity and appreciation. Not a life changing decision. 

  •  Mortgages are all below 3% and mortgage interest + property taxes allow them to claim ~$25k in itemized deductions (their CPA already doing this, no changes here).

Estate Planning 

  • They will be under the $15M exemption per individual ($30M married combined) federal limit 

  • They have a living trust; tax-advantaged accounts cannot go into a living trust but if he moved the brokerage account into the trust (no tax consequences) it would not be subject to probate 

  • Their estate will likely be subject to state tax, so we discussed options of how to move money out of the estate via a Spousal Lifetime Access Trust (SLAT) or Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT) if their goal is to reduce estate tax


Kids 

  • 529 contributions are growing okay. At their level of wealth it’s not necessary to force contributions into a 529 account just for the sake of it, if money is being saved appropriately elsewhere. If kids go onto business payroll they can contribute to their own Roth IRA. 

  • Husband read up on UTMA accounts and asked me about it. The answer is yes, $19k/year per parent, gift-tax free to children and it doesn’t need to be used towards eligible education expenses the way that a 529 does  

  • Under my roth conversion plan they should be able to wealth transfer up to $3.9M down to their children, tax-free

Going back to husband’s original concerns: yes, they can retire at 50. Projected net worth of about $8-9M by 50, which factors the amortization of their real estate debt with no additional mortgage pay down.

Alice

P.S. If you are a HNW family and are done DIY-ing your portfolio from social media gurus and want to talk to me 🤓 instead … shoot me a message here or just reply to this email.

Any personally identifiable details have been revoked to protect client privacy.  Figures are projections based on assumptions, not guarantees. This email is for education only and isn't individual tax, legal or investment advice.